Thursday, February 23, 2012

USA Today’s Somewhat Flawed Candidate Match Game

A few days ago, my mother forwarded me a link to USA Today’s Candidate Match Game. I played the game and to no great surprise, the candidate who best matched my answers to the issues was President Obama (with Jon Huntsman running a distant second). Go ahead. Click over and play the game. I’ll wait…

Done? Cool. Which candidate best matched your thoughts on the issues? Were you surprised?

So now let’s take a closer look at the “game” itself. First, let’s look at the 11 issues presented in the game:

  • Afghanistan
  • Energy
  • Health Care
  • Medicare
  • Immigration
  • Experience
  • Social Security
  • Climate Change
  • Taxes
  • Defense Spending
  • Gay Marriage

That’s certainly a decent set of issues. But do you notice any important issues missing from that list? What about job creation? That seems like a fairly important issue these days, don’t you think? What about states rights (i.e., the ability of states to opt out of federal laws or to claim that many federal laws are an unconstitutional infringement on the rights of the states). That’s something that the Republicans have been talking about quite a bit (often in terms of the 10th Amendment). What about the rights of women and other minorities (whether it be things like equal pay, access to birth control, or affirmative action)? What about Iran and whether we should continue to try to negotiate or simply begin the attack? Abortion, anyone? Financial oversight (i.e., “too big to fail” and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)? And what about efforts to cut government spending and reduce the debt (other than just with cuts to the military)? The Republicans talk a lot about cutting this department, that agency, or bunches of programs (like, for example, the EPA or the Department of Education). It seems to me that those are also important issues that would help people determine which candidate best matches their thoughts.

I raise these issues because it seems to me that the selection of issues included in USA Today’s game seems to skew somewhat toward the issues that Republicans are talking about. If the point of the game were just to determine which Republican most closely meets your ideas, then that’s fine. But the game also includes President Obama as a possible outcome. Think for a moment of your own answers and results. Now pretend that the game had included questions on methods to spur job creation, whether states can opt out of federal laws and mandates, minority rights, abortion, and methods to reduce the debt and cut spending (among other possible categories). We haven’t heard President Obama talk much about the 10th Amendment but we have heard him talk about job creation. Thinking broadly about how you might answer those questions, do you think you would have skewed further toward President Obama or toward one of the Republican candidates?

And let’s dig a bit deeper on a few of the questions that were asked. For example, the question on health care offers four choices (plus “none of the above”); three choices involve repealing the new health care law while the fourth choice is to simply “support” the health care law. The problem here is that many on the left of the spectrum feel that the Affordable Care Act didn’t go far enough. Many were upset that the law didn’t include a “government option” or single payer system. And many were upset that the law didn’t really address the cost of health care, including such problems as re-importation of drugs. Some who may generally support the Affordable Care Act may not click on the “support” answer because they want it to be enhanced and aren’t satisfied with how it stands at present. So the omission of that sort of answer choice may skew respondents away from President Obama.

Or take the question on immigration. Three of the four substantive answers include tighter border security (and the fourth implies it); but none of the options suggest making immigration easier or more fair. One of the answers talks about extending some privileges to illegal immigrants who have ties in the community, but none of the options makes mention of actually granting some form of amnesty or establishing a guest worker program. Thus, again, it appears that the choices seem to skew toward the Republicans … or at least what the Republicans are talking about.

The answers to the question on Social Security are really oddly worded. For example, the first two answers appear to only differ in whether or not the retirement age is raised, but the second answer adds in a suggestion of means testing. Both means testing and retirement age are important things to consider, but it seems that to really approach those issues, you’d need a matrix of four, not two, possible answers. This problem is exacerbated by the next answer which again talks about raising the retirement age and links that to private accounts with no mention of means testing.

Or consider the wording on the cap-and-trade answer to the climate change question: “Reduce greenhouse gas emissions through a cap-and-trade system that would force industries to pay for exceeding limits.” The problem with that answer is that it is one of those leading answers that suggests a response to the casual reader not well-versed in the issues; after all, who wants to make industries pay more? The answer doesn’t provide the context (the whole cap-and-trade concept) that allows industries that have reduced their pollution to trade their pollution credits to industries that are still polluting and provides a time frame for the reduction of pollution. Note further that the answers don’t really provide any real response other than “no” for those who disagree with cap-and-trade … because none of the Republican candidates have really put forth any proposals.

The answers to the question on taxation are also somewhat odd. Most notable is the omission of any reference to the Buffett Rule. Similarly, there is reference to allowing the Bush tax cuts to expire … but no mention of raising taxes on the wealthiest.

Finally, with regard to gay marriage, it seems that there should be an option for those who actually support gay marriage.

Yes, I understand that those who crafted the game tried to limit answers to things that the various candidates have proposed. However, as written, that winds up giving lots of choices within the field of Republican candidates but only a single “correct” answer on the “left”.

Thus, when you combine the issues being addressed with the types of answers offered for those issues, I can’t help but feel that the entire game skews to the right, even if not toward any particular candidate. And I do think that the omission of questions relevant to the economy, in particular (other than a single question on taxes) may tend to have more people “choosing” a Republican than otherwise would if there were more questions on these core issues. With just one more question, focusing on job creation, for example, how many people’s chosen candidate would have switched from a Republican to President Obama (or the other way, I suppose)? Given that most polling shows that the economy and job creation is at the top of almost all lists of issues important to voters, the omission of that topic is highly problematic.

And, given the recent flap over birth control and abortion (among other social issues), that gay marriage is the only social issue included is also problematic. I can see many people disagreeing with gay marriage but also disagreeing with the anti-abortion or anti-contraception stance of many of the Republicans. So the choice of one particular social issue doesn’t lead to a very useful understanding of the host of social issues that may influence a person’s vote or help someone determine which candidate best matches their views, especially if that particular voter rates social issues high on their scale of importance.

Nevertheless, the “game” does provide a useful, if limited, opportunity for people to compare their thoughts on some issues to those espoused by the candidates. As the general election draws nearer, I’d love to seem a much more detailed version of this game with far more questions and much more detailed answers and choices. Now that would be a game worth playing.

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share


17 Comments:

At Thursday, August 22, 2019 8:57:00 AM , Blogger Simon Kirbey said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At Monday, October 14, 2019 4:42:00 PM , Blogger unknown said...

What a nice blog! I have enjoyed reading through the article although I landed on this site while I was looking for drip irrigation systems in Kenya. I will be visiting this site occasionally to read more interesting and intriguing articles. I hope the writer will continually keep us updated with new information.

 
At Friday, October 18, 2019 5:13:00 AM , Blogger john amber said...

I suggest all members choose assignment help Australia for the best guideline in your academia. The perfect and expert assistant your requirement and learning assignment project by the university.

 
At Friday, October 18, 2019 9:27:00 AM , Blogger Chauhan Mandis said...

QuickBooks is one of the largest Software in Accounting and Bookkeeping, which has improved its reputation globally.The majority of the individuals that are extremely knowledgeable about the QuickBooks. then visit my website and service.

QuickBooks Payroll Error Code 30159
QuickBooks Error code 5502

 
At Saturday, November 02, 2019 7:00:00 AM , Blogger adam hebrew said...

Such a nice blog post on this topic. After graduating from an eminent UK university, I worked as a dissertation writer for several years. Now I assist students in writing dissertations. Due to I expertise, I compose All dissertation help Uk students. I procure customized and appropriate format based on one of the best academic referencing styles including Harvard, APA, Chicago and MLA referencing styles.

 
At Friday, November 15, 2019 1:39:00 AM , Blogger Andy Alvin said...

Avail and Buy cheap case study Assignment, kraft foods pestel analysis and best hr case studies with solutions at MyAssignmentHelp. We are a wide range of experts available 24*7 to assist students around the globe.

 
At Friday, November 15, 2019 4:05:00 AM , Blogger georgethomas said...

Thanks for your suggestion. But I prefer taking help from GoAssignmentHelp for commercial law assignment help because I have used their service for so many times and I’m enthralled with the outcomes.

 
At Monday, November 18, 2019 2:10:00 AM , Blogger Max Willor said...

A special thanks to My Assignment Help for providing a well-written assignment. You guys were a savior to me. Will contact you soon for my upcoming assignments. You can email us at cs@Myassignmenthelpau.Com or Phone Number: +61-2-8005-8227

 
At Wednesday, November 27, 2019 1:10:00 AM , Blogger QuickBooks Premier Support said...

Thanks for sharing such an informative post.
The QuickBooks Error Code 6189 is also commonly known as ‘runtime error’. This error code usually arises while the QB Company file opens or runs.
QuickBooks Desktop Pro is a piece of accounting software that offers robust features with creative functionalities for core accounting software applications consisting account payable & receivable. Just give us one perfect call to our experts at QuickBooks Pro Support Helpine Number +1-800-969-7370.

 
At Saturday, November 30, 2019 4:03:00 AM , Blogger QuickBooks Enterprise Support said...

I am really glad I have found this information.
If you use QuickBooks Pro or Premier, it might be time to upgrade to QuickBooks Enterprise.
QuickBooks is awesome software which is made to make accounting and bookkeeping easier. You could possibly stump to “QBDBMGRN not running on this computer” when using QuickBooks in multi-user mode.

 
At Thursday, December 12, 2019 3:56:00 AM , Blogger Wewpyou said...

Hi i am a technical content writer and I take great interest in writing about Wordpress and other similar development platforms. My vast experience in the field of development helps me to keep my blogs simple yet informing. I try to cover all the topics related to WordPress. My blogs include everything from tutorials to how-to guides, Updates to latest news about technology.
stripe fees vs paypal
paypal or stripe
stripe versus paypal
paypal vs stripe
stripe micropayments

 
At Thursday, December 19, 2019 12:48:00 PM , Blogger Binary said...

Thank you for sharing great content. Will be your occasional visitor. Drip Irrigation is a kind of micro-irrigation system that delivers water slowly at a low pressure near or at the root zone of the plants. Get Best drip emitters today

 
At Tuesday, December 24, 2019 12:28:00 AM , Blogger JOHN SMITH said...

Thanks for sharing this link about Candidate Match Game. Maybe I will play this game later. Here I am sharing useful link for students all across the globe. Dissertation Editing Service

 
At Tuesday, January 07, 2020 3:50:00 AM , Blogger Assignment Helper said...

Online Assignment Help acts as an easy and convenient method to opt for experts’ assistance for submitting any academic task within the defined time. So, if you have stress for your assignment, refer to professional writers.
Assignment Help
assignment help service
Assignment help services
Help with my assignment
Assignment Helper

 
At Wednesday, January 08, 2020 12:01:00 AM , Blogger Manish Kumar said...

Amazing post! This blog gives wonderful ideas to visit Most Beautiful Places In The World. It gives easy tips to visit these places for new tourists. Thanks for sharing this amazing post!

 
At Wednesday, January 08, 2020 9:19:00 AM , Blogger James Marcus said...

Thanks for your valuable post. Please post some more related topics. We are on your page only to read your blog because, as you know, there are no other for being here. Like you, we also here for some information of Outlook, so if any of you need any type of help related Outlook then contact our Outlook support phone number or visit the website.
How do I contact Outlook support?
How do I contact outlook by phone?
Outlook Support Phone Number
Microsoft Outlook Support

 
At Monday, January 20, 2020 4:28:00 AM , Blogger RealMailFix said...

Download AOL Desktop Gold Software and installation on windows 10
How to Download AOL Desktop Gold Software To install AOL desktop gold all you need to do is to located aol gold downloaded file. After clicking on the downloaded AOL gold desktop setup file, tap for "AOL desktop gold Install" icon. Choose "Run" on the forthcoming tab on your computer screen.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

Newer›  ‹Older