Thursday, February 23, 2012

USA Today’s Somewhat Flawed Candidate Match Game

A few days ago, my mother forwarded me a link to USA Today’s Candidate Match Game. I played the game and to no great surprise, the candidate who best matched my answers to the issues was President Obama (with Jon Huntsman running a distant second). Go ahead. Click over and play the game. I’ll wait…

Done? Cool. Which candidate best matched your thoughts on the issues? Were you surprised?

So now let’s take a closer look at the “game” itself. First, let’s look at the 11 issues presented in the game:

  • Afghanistan
  • Energy
  • Health Care
  • Medicare
  • Immigration
  • Experience
  • Social Security
  • Climate Change
  • Taxes
  • Defense Spending
  • Gay Marriage

That’s certainly a decent set of issues. But do you notice any important issues missing from that list? What about job creation? That seems like a fairly important issue these days, don’t you think? What about states rights (i.e., the ability of states to opt out of federal laws or to claim that many federal laws are an unconstitutional infringement on the rights of the states). That’s something that the Republicans have been talking about quite a bit (often in terms of the 10th Amendment). What about the rights of women and other minorities (whether it be things like equal pay, access to birth control, or affirmative action)? What about Iran and whether we should continue to try to negotiate or simply begin the attack? Abortion, anyone? Financial oversight (i.e., “too big to fail” and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)? And what about efforts to cut government spending and reduce the debt (other than just with cuts to the military)? The Republicans talk a lot about cutting this department, that agency, or bunches of programs (like, for example, the EPA or the Department of Education). It seems to me that those are also important issues that would help people determine which candidate best matches their thoughts.

I raise these issues because it seems to me that the selection of issues included in USA Today’s game seems to skew somewhat toward the issues that Republicans are talking about. If the point of the game were just to determine which Republican most closely meets your ideas, then that’s fine. But the game also includes President Obama as a possible outcome. Think for a moment of your own answers and results. Now pretend that the game had included questions on methods to spur job creation, whether states can opt out of federal laws and mandates, minority rights, abortion, and methods to reduce the debt and cut spending (among other possible categories). We haven’t heard President Obama talk much about the 10th Amendment but we have heard him talk about job creation. Thinking broadly about how you might answer those questions, do you think you would have skewed further toward President Obama or toward one of the Republican candidates?

And let’s dig a bit deeper on a few of the questions that were asked. For example, the question on health care offers four choices (plus “none of the above”); three choices involve repealing the new health care law while the fourth choice is to simply “support” the health care law. The problem here is that many on the left of the spectrum feel that the Affordable Care Act didn’t go far enough. Many were upset that the law didn’t include a “government option” or single payer system. And many were upset that the law didn’t really address the cost of health care, including such problems as re-importation of drugs. Some who may generally support the Affordable Care Act may not click on the “support” answer because they want it to be enhanced and aren’t satisfied with how it stands at present. So the omission of that sort of answer choice may skew respondents away from President Obama.

Or take the question on immigration. Three of the four substantive answers include tighter border security (and the fourth implies it); but none of the options suggest making immigration easier or more fair. One of the answers talks about extending some privileges to illegal immigrants who have ties in the community, but none of the options makes mention of actually granting some form of amnesty or establishing a guest worker program. Thus, again, it appears that the choices seem to skew toward the Republicans … or at least what the Republicans are talking about.

The answers to the question on Social Security are really oddly worded. For example, the first two answers appear to only differ in whether or not the retirement age is raised, but the second answer adds in a suggestion of means testing. Both means testing and retirement age are important things to consider, but it seems that to really approach those issues, you’d need a matrix of four, not two, possible answers. This problem is exacerbated by the next answer which again talks about raising the retirement age and links that to private accounts with no mention of means testing.

Or consider the wording on the cap-and-trade answer to the climate change question: “Reduce greenhouse gas emissions through a cap-and-trade system that would force industries to pay for exceeding limits.” The problem with that answer is that it is one of those leading answers that suggests a response to the casual reader not well-versed in the issues; after all, who wants to make industries pay more? The answer doesn’t provide the context (the whole cap-and-trade concept) that allows industries that have reduced their pollution to trade their pollution credits to industries that are still polluting and provides a time frame for the reduction of pollution. Note further that the answers don’t really provide any real response other than “no” for those who disagree with cap-and-trade … because none of the Republican candidates have really put forth any proposals.

The answers to the question on taxation are also somewhat odd. Most notable is the omission of any reference to the Buffett Rule. Similarly, there is reference to allowing the Bush tax cuts to expire … but no mention of raising taxes on the wealthiest.

Finally, with regard to gay marriage, it seems that there should be an option for those who actually support gay marriage.

Yes, I understand that those who crafted the game tried to limit answers to things that the various candidates have proposed. However, as written, that winds up giving lots of choices within the field of Republican candidates but only a single “correct” answer on the “left”.

Thus, when you combine the issues being addressed with the types of answers offered for those issues, I can’t help but feel that the entire game skews to the right, even if not toward any particular candidate. And I do think that the omission of questions relevant to the economy, in particular (other than a single question on taxes) may tend to have more people “choosing” a Republican than otherwise would if there were more questions on these core issues. With just one more question, focusing on job creation, for example, how many people’s chosen candidate would have switched from a Republican to President Obama (or the other way, I suppose)? Given that most polling shows that the economy and job creation is at the top of almost all lists of issues important to voters, the omission of that topic is highly problematic.

And, given the recent flap over birth control and abortion (among other social issues), that gay marriage is the only social issue included is also problematic. I can see many people disagreeing with gay marriage but also disagreeing with the anti-abortion or anti-contraception stance of many of the Republicans. So the choice of one particular social issue doesn’t lead to a very useful understanding of the host of social issues that may influence a person’s vote or help someone determine which candidate best matches their views, especially if that particular voter rates social issues high on their scale of importance.

Nevertheless, the “game” does provide a useful, if limited, opportunity for people to compare their thoughts on some issues to those espoused by the candidates. As the general election draws nearer, I’d love to seem a much more detailed version of this game with far more questions and much more detailed answers and choices. Now that would be a game worth playing.

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share


21 Comments:

At Wednesday, April 17, 2019 5:06:00 AM , Blogger midn said...

Top replique de luxe montres series, combining elegant style and cutting-edge watchmaking technology, a variety of styles of high-end replique patek philippe montres, the pointer walks between your exclusive taste style.

 
At Monday, June 17, 2019 5:00:00 AM , Blogger Nathan William said...

One of the most prominent issues the students have to deal with while writing assignments is plagiarism. Hence, they extensively use plagiarism checker to check if there are any copied content in the paper.
Another major reason for using plagiarism checker is that universities do not accept plagiarized content. Plagiarism is a serious offence. Hence, if found, the students are suspended or might even lose the grades.Choose Myassignmenthelp.com.
Myassignmenthelp.com is a leading homework help service provider company. We are specializing in providing complete homework help solution for the students who want to get quality service to relief from their homework. Here you can get right answer and service on “can anyone do my math homework for me?” Hire our top expert to find any types of homework assistance at reasonable price.

 
At Saturday, June 29, 2019 5:07:00 AM , Blogger rickypauls said...

This is a really informative post. If students require any help regarding their assignments, they must try for Assignment Help Services. Website greatassignmenthelp offers reliable and trustworthy services with the help of best academic writers and editors. One can approach them for remarkable writing services.
Assignment Help Online
Online Assignment Help
Assignment Help Online Services
Assignment Helper
Assignment Assistance
Assignment Help Experts
Online Assignment Help Services
Assignment Writing Help

 
At Sunday, June 30, 2019 11:31:00 AM , Blogger Rishma Hauser said...

Dit is het leuke blog van Avast Antivirus. Klanten komen langs het spoor en maken 24 uur per dag en 7 dagen per week contact met het professionele ondersteuningsteam. als u met de installatie- en reparatieservice op een computersysteem wordt geconfronteerd. er is een groot probleem met het venster 7, venster 8 en venster 10. gebruikers zijn regelmatig bezig met het installeren van Avast Antivirus.
avast contact
Avast klantenservice België
Avast Belgie Telefoonnummer
Avast Telefoonnummer Belgie
Avast Telefoonnummer
Avast helpdesk Belgie
Telefoonnummer Avast Belgie
Telefoonnummer Avast
Avast Ondersteuning
Avast klantenservice Belgie Telefoonnummer
avast helpdesk
avast telefoonnummer
klantenservice avast
avast software klantenservice
avast klantenservice
avast bellen
contact met avast

 
At Monday, July 08, 2019 2:31:00 AM , Blogger myassignmenthelpau said...

This post is not just informative but impressive also. The post is so convincing that it created an urge to choose Nursing Assignment Help services. You can email us at cs@Myassignmenthelpau.Com or Phone Number: +61-2-8005-8227

 
At Saturday, July 20, 2019 7:19:00 AM , Blogger Ideal Assignment Help said...

Such an impressive share! It is well-written and contains all the info, your Post is very unique and all the information is reliable for new readers. We provide high-quality my assignment help services within the given time frame and guaranteed grades!

 
At Friday, July 26, 2019 1:51:00 AM , Blogger Stefan Carl said...

Get help in your assignments from StudentsAssignmentHelp.com. If you have any problem in writing your assignments then you can say our experts to do my assignments UK.

 
At Monday, August 12, 2019 2:22:00 AM , Blogger William Shell said...

Hey, Your blog is very informative. It is nice to read such high-quality content. Attractive information on your blog, thank you for taking the time and share with us. Myassignmenthelp delivers high-quality content related to help with employee motivation assignment.

 
At Wednesday, August 14, 2019 7:52:00 AM , Blogger Ethan Lee said...

Amaze your professors this term with an A+ grade by availing our science homework help. We have top experts who can draft your homework prudently. We also have domain-specific qualified writers on board who can ease your burden instantly. Trust us and you will never have to look for an answer to why it takes so long for you to do your Science Homework. If you get our perfect science answers for homework, achieving academic success will no more be a hassle.
We have served thousands of clients who needed assistance for writing cover letters for different purposes. You may have the need for writing cover letters for job application or you might be applying for a specific course at a reputed institute. Whatever the purpose of writing a cover letter is, you will get the necessary help from us.
Also, you can use an paraphrasing tool to rewrite your resume and cover letter for a better job opportunity.

 
At Friday, August 16, 2019 7:47:00 AM , Blogger adam hebrew said...

Nice post, We have a team of excellent dissertation writer who is Ph.D. certified and have years of experience in providing high-quality dissertation writing service. The team of our skilled writers has satisfied several students in UK. Our mission is to de-stress the students suffering from excessive academic writing pressure by offering them original content written from scratch. We ensure our customers a 100% plagiarism free paper at an affordable price range. Avail our services and get your dream to score high grades fulfilled.

 
At Tuesday, August 20, 2019 6:14:00 AM , Blogger John Trump said...

To record a vehicle purchase in QuickBooks you have to follow some steps. To know how to record a vehicle purchase in QuickBooks contact QuickBooks Support Number 1-877-263-2742.
how to record a vehicle purchase in QuickBooks | QuickBooks Error 6094 | QuickBooks Error Code 64 | qbo login

 
At Wednesday, August 21, 2019 7:39:00 AM , Blogger Suhana Williams said...

Our services for USA accounting assignment help are created with the belief that multitasking accomplishes nothing. If you are also looking for professional English assignment help online, you have come to the right place. Our team of expert math assignment solver has made a name for themselves as a quality math assignment help provider all over the United States.

 
At Thursday, August 22, 2019 8:57:00 AM , Blogger Simon Kirbey said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At Thursday, August 22, 2019 8:58:00 AM , Blogger Simon Kirbey said...

Myassignmenthelp provides best Math Homework Help services in USA to solve your math problem by math homework solver.

 
At Tuesday, September 03, 2019 8:52:00 AM , Blogger Ethan Lee said...

Pay for essay writing at MyAssignmenthelp and you will have enough time to take care of your personal tasks. Prepare for your online exams or take care of your family without any stress. Got a party to attend? Need a vacation to de-stress yourself? Well, congratulations, since you have found someone who will handle your essay writing tasks.
Do you often look for college essay help online due to a massive time constraint? Do you often wish for a Genie who could complete all your essay papers in a snap? Well, Genies may not be real, but we have got the next best thing for you – professional college essay writers.

 
At Thursday, September 05, 2019 7:17:00 AM , Blogger Erick Bana said...

The area of finance consists of many different branches, it is possible to get stuck at some point. Hiring our finance homework help online would ensure your academic progress is never hampered. Irrespective of the topic you are working on, our finance homework solutions will sort out your concerns.
Tophomeworkhelper.com will always help you to stay at the brighter side of the story. Being the best statistics homework help provider in town, we are dedicated to covering each and every sub-disciplinary area associated with the subject. Now that you are eager to know about our areas of expertise, here’s a glimpse of the key areas we cover.
Your search for trusted college homework help online ends with TophomeworkHelper.com. Not only do we provide the widest range of college homework, but we also have the best minds in the industry to assist us. Check out the subjects that we usually cover (to name a few) and our team of experts will zero in on the specific kind of college homework help.

 
At Monday, September 09, 2019 7:29:00 AM , Blogger Keira Tayor said...

An
assignment writing service requires you to conduct a profound research on the given topic. Our Australian assignment help experts are conversant with each researching tool required for gathering authentic resources to get assignment help online.
Moreover, all our assignment writers went under a thorough training session to understand the essentials of academic writing. They have been introduced to various referencing styles and formatting of all existing academic assignments.
If you are seeking help for writing essays, we have team essay experts who are capable of providing quality essays within given time limit. So whenever you need help with any type of essay writing, for example, analysis essay, don’t hesitate to contact us for assignment assistance.

 
At Tuesday, September 10, 2019 2:45:00 AM , Blogger Chauhan Mandis said...

I love your article so much and I appreciate your thought and views. This is really great work. Thank you for sharing such a useful information here on the blog.

Convert Data File From QuickBooks Online to Desktop

How to Access QuickBooks Remotely

QuickBooks Installation Error Codes 1904, 1402

 
At Tuesday, September 10, 2019 7:58:00 AM , Blogger ireland assignment help said...

Students in Ireland now do not need to worry about their academic writing needs as the experts of IrelandAssignmentHelp.com are here with their Essay help services to assist and guide students. To avail, our excellent services email us at info@irelandassignmenthelp.com, and you just sit back and relax.

 
At Friday, September 13, 2019 3:23:00 AM , Blogger Erick Bana said...

With 4.9 out of 5 on customer satisfaction ratings and superb reviews, we reign supreme among all Geography homework help providers in town. And it is not only the stellar quality of our homework solutions that make us shine so bright.

Are you on the verge of a meltdown over your finance paper? Assistance is around the corner with finance homework help from TopHomeworkhelper.com. You only have to ask, “Can anyone do my finance homework for me?” and our experts will weave their magic on your finance homework solutions.

Seeking online statistics homework help from Tophomeworkhelper.com will always help you to stay at the brighter side of the story. Being the best statistics homework help provider in town, we are dedicated to covering each and every sub-disciplinary area associated with the subject. Now that you are eager to know about our areas of expertise, here’s a glimpse of the key areas we cover.

We have the world’s best history helpers who have acquired their Ph.D. degrees in the field from reputed Universities. They have an experience of at least 7 years in academic writing. Your history homework can take many shapes. It can be a research paper or an essay. No matter what type of history homework you have been assigned.

Not many of you know this, but once you find an answer to the query "Who can do my college homework?”, you open up a world of possibilities. You don’t have to worry about missing deadlines for your college homework assignments anymore. All you need to do is to place an order with our 3000+ PhD-qualified writers. Get top-notch help with college homework, and focus on the fun things this term.

Our team of 3000+ experts provides guidance with a wide variety of subjects and covers over 100+ areas of science. Most of our writers are PhD graduates and retired professors with years of experience in dealing with various fields of science subjects. Our experts on science homework helpers online provide comprehensive solutions on each and every topic.

 
At Wednesday, September 18, 2019 5:57:00 AM , Blogger anika kennedy said...

Thankyou so much for sharing awesome information.Nowadays assignment work is emphasized the most but enough time to prepare these assignments is not given to students due to other course works. My Assignment Experts deliver the best all assignment to all students who are seeking help from best-qualified assignment experts who are available at any time to help the students.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

Newer›  ‹Older